Nickels US For Sale In NEW JERSEY - Live and Online Auction Lots

Nickels US For Sale In NEW JERSEY
Auctions Map Lots
Hide Search Bar
Shipping Available
Single Page
Showing 1 to 83 of 83 lots
Featured On HiBid.com
Key Date Coins Weekend Special- $1 Openings! LD50
Key Date Coins
1031 Lots - Ends 12/21/2024
Dec 18th - 22nd Seattle Sage Coin Auction
Dec 18th - 22nd Seattle Sage Coin Auction
Gold Standard Auctions
3850 Lots - Ends 12/22/2024
prev
next
Lot 5771 |

*Highlight* 1913-p Ty I Buffalo Nickel 5c ms67 SEG
Watch
*Highlight* 1913-p Ty I Buffalo Nickel 5c ms67 SEG
High Bid: 10.00 USD
687.50 - 687.50 USD
2 Bids
Lot 5795 |

*Highlight* 1934-d Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c
Watch
*Highlight* 1934-d Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c
High Bid: 5.00 USD
843.75 - 843.75 USD
1 Bid
Lot 5819 |

*Highlight* 1916-p Buffalo Nickel 5c ms66+ SEGS (f
Watch
*Highlight* 1916-p Buffalo Nickel 5c ms66+ SEGS (f
High Bid: 5.00 USD
1,153.13 - 1,153.13 USD
1 Bid
Lot 5843 |

*Highlight* 1913-s Ty I Buffalo Nickel Near Top Po
Watch
*Highlight* 1913-s Ty I Buffalo Nickel Near Top Po
High Bid: 5.00 USD
1,475.00 - 1,475.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 5867 |

*Highlight* 1919-p Buffalo Nickel 5c ms67 SEGS (fc
Watch
*Highlight* 1919-p Buffalo Nickel 5c ms67 SEGS (fc
High Bid: 5.00 USD
2,375.00 - 2,375.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 5891 |

*Highlight* 1938-d/d Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms
Watch
*Highlight* 1938-d/d Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms
High Bid: 10.00 USD
17,500.00 - 17,500.00 USD
2 Bids
Lot 5915 |

*Highlight* 1913-d Ty I Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c
Watch
*Highlight* 1913-d Ty I Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c
High Bid: 180.00 USD
25,000.00 - 25,000.00 USD
3 Bids
Lot 5939 |

*Highlight* 1926-p Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
Watch
*Highlight* 1926-p Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
High Bid: 80.00 USD
25,000.00 - 25,000.00 USD
2 Bids
Lot 5963 |

*Highlight* 1915-p Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
Watch
*Highlight* 1915-p Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
High Bid: 5.00 USD
35,000.00 - 35,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 5987 |

*Highlight* 1928-p Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms67
Watch
*Highlight* 1928-p Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms67
High Bid: 5.00 USD
3,937.50 - 3,937.50 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6011 |

*Highlight* 1936-d Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c
Watch
*Highlight* 1936-d Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c
High Bid: 5.00 USD
4,256.25 - 4,256.25 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6035 |

*Highlight* 1938-d Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
Watch
*Highlight* 1938-d Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
High Bid: 10.00 USD
6,937.50 - 6,937.50 USD
2 Bids
Lot 6059 |

*Highlight* 1923-s Buffalo Nickel 5c ms65+ SEGS (f
Watch
*Highlight* 1923-s Buffalo Nickel 5c ms65+ SEGS (f
High Bid: 5.00 USD
7,906.25 - 7,906.25 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6083 |

*Highlight* 1937-s Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
Watch
*Highlight* 1937-s Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
High Bid: 40.00 USD
9,000.00 - 9,000.00 USD
2 Bids
Lot 6107 |

*Highlight* 1937-d Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
Watch
*Highlight* 1937-d Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
High Bid: 10.00 USD
11,250.00 - 11,250.00 USD
2 Bids
Lot 6131 |

*Highlight* 1918-d Buffalo Nickel 5c ms65+ SEGS (f
Watch
*Highlight* 1918-d Buffalo Nickel 5c ms65+ SEGS (f
High Bid: 5.00 USD
2,781.25 - 2,781.25 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6133 |

*Highlight* 1876 Proof Three Cent Copper Nickel 3c
Watch
*Highlight* 1876 Proof Three Cent Copper Nickel 3c
High Bid: 5.00 USD
1,000.00 - 2,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6138 |

*Highlight* 1883 Shield Nickel 5c ms67+ SEGS (fc)
Watch
*Highlight* 1883 Shield Nickel 5c ms67+ SEGS (fc)
High Bid: 5.00 USD
3,500.00 - 3,500.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6154 |

*Highlight* 1879/8 Proof Shield Nickel 5c pr67+ ca
Watch
*Highlight* 1879/8 Proof Shield Nickel 5c pr67+ ca
High Bid: 5.00 USD
6,250.00 - 12,500.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6155 |

*Highlight* 1915 Proof Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop
Watch
*Highlight* 1915 Proof Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop
High Bid: 5.00 USD
1,000.00 - 2,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6179 |

*Highlight* 1937-d 3 Leg Buffalo Nickel 5c Select+
Watch
*Highlight* 1937-d 3 Leg Buffalo Nickel 5c Select+
High Bid: 180.00 USD
3,687.50 - 3,687.50 USD
2 Bids
Lot 6193 |

*Highlight* 1884 Liberty Nickel Colorfully Toned T
Watch
*Highlight* 1884 Liberty Nickel Colorfully Toned T
High Bid: 5.00 USD
20,000.00 - 20,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6203 |

*Highlight* 1938-d/s Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms
Watch
*Highlight* 1938-d/s Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms
High Bid: 40.00 USD
11,062.50 - 11,062.50 USD
2 Bids
Lot 6227 |

*Highlight* PCGS 1929-p Buffalo Nickel Near Top Po
Watch
*Highlight* PCGS 1929-p Buffalo Nickel Near Top Po
High Bid: 5.00 USD
25,000.00 - 25,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6239 |

*Highlight* 1879 Proof Three Cent Copper Nickel TO
Watch
*Highlight* 1879 Proof Three Cent Copper Nickel TO
High Bid: 5.00 USD
25,000.00 - 50,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6241 |

*Highlight* 1906 Proof Liberty Nickel TOP POP! 5c
Watch
*Highlight* 1906 Proof Liberty Nickel TOP POP! 5c
High Bid: 5.00 USD
45,000.00 - 90,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6251 |

*Highlight* 1913 Ty 2 Proof Buffalo Nickel 5c pr68
Watch
*Highlight* 1913 Ty 2 Proof Buffalo Nickel 5c pr68
High Bid: 5.00 USD
22,500.00 - 45,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6275 |

*Highlight* 1915-p Buffalo Nickel 5c ms68 SEGS (fc
Watch
*Highlight* 1915-p Buffalo Nickel 5c ms68 SEGS (fc
High Bid: 180.00 USD
35,000.00 - 70,000.00 USD
2 Bids
Lot 6299 |

*Highlight* 1917-s Buffalo Nickel 5c ms67 SEGS (fc
Watch
*Highlight* 1917-s Buffalo Nickel 5c ms67 SEGS (fc
High Bid: 5.00 USD
30,000.00 - 30,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6310 |

*Highlight* 1878 Proof Shield Nickel Near Top Pop!
Watch
*Highlight* 1878 Proof Shield Nickel Near Top Pop!
High Bid: 5.00 USD
8,250.00 - 16,500.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6323 |

*Highlight* 1918-d Buffalo Nickel 5c ms67 SEGS (fc
Watch
*Highlight* 1918-d Buffalo Nickel 5c ms67 SEGS (fc
High Bid: 5.00 USD
20,000.00 - 20,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6342 |

*Highlight* PCGS 1858 Judd-206, Pollock-242, R.5 P
Watch
*Highlight* PCGS 1858 Judd-206, Pollock-242, R.5 P
High Bid: 5.00 USD
5,000.00 - 10,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6347 |

*Highlight* 1937-d 3 Leg Buffalo Nickel 5c Choice
Watch
*Highlight* 1937-d 3 Leg Buffalo Nickel 5c Choice
High Bid: 325.00 USD
5,000.00 - 5,000.00 USD
2 Bids
Lot 6371 |

*Highlight* 1920-d Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c
Watch
*Highlight* 1920-d Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c
High Bid: 5.00 USD
33,125.00 - 33,125.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6395 |

*Highlight* PCGS 1929-p Buffalo Nickel Near Top Po
Watch
*Highlight* PCGS 1929-p Buffalo Nickel Near Top Po
High Bid: 5.00 USD
25,000.00 - 25,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6397 |

*Highlight* 1893 Proof Liberty Nickel 5c pr68 DCAM
Watch
*Highlight* 1893 Proof Liberty Nickel 5c pr68 DCAM
High Bid: 5.00 USD
8,750.00 - 17,500.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6419 |

*Highlight* 1913-s Ty I Buffalo Nickel Colorfully
Watch
*Highlight* 1913-s Ty I Buffalo Nickel Colorfully
High Bid: 5.00 USD
30,000.00 - 30,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6433 |

*Highlight* 1912 Liberty Nickel Colorfully Toned 5
Watch
*Highlight* 1912 Liberty Nickel Colorfully Toned 5
High Bid: 5.00 USD
5,000.00 - 10,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6443 |

*Highlight* 1914 Proof Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop
Watch
*Highlight* 1914 Proof Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop
High Bid: 5.00 USD
7,000.00 - 14,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6457 |

*Highlight* 1873 Closed 3 Three Cent Copper Nickel
Watch
*Highlight* 1873 Closed 3 Three Cent Copper Nickel
High Bid: 5.00 USD
5,000.00 - 5,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6467 |

*Highlight* 1927-p Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
Watch
*Highlight* 1927-p Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
High Bid: 5.00 USD
20,312.50 - 20,312.50 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6491 |

*Highlight* 1927-p Buffalo Nickel 5c ms66+ SEGS (f
Watch
*Highlight* 1927-p Buffalo Nickel 5c ms66+ SEGS (f
High Bid: 5.00 USD
743.75 - 743.75 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6511 |

1938-s Jefferson Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c ms67+ SEG
Watch
1938-s Jefferson Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c ms67+ SEG
High Bid: 80.00 USD
343.75 - 343.75 USD
3 Bids
Lot 6515 |

*Highlight* 1938-d Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c
Watch
*Highlight* 1938-d Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c
High Bid: 140.00 USD
1,165.63 - 1,165.63 USD
3 Bids
Lot 6539 |

*Highlight* 1923-p Buffalo Nickel 5c ms66+ SEGS (f
Watch
*Highlight* 1923-p Buffalo Nickel 5c ms66+ SEGS (f
High Bid: 5.00 USD
1,187.50 - 1,187.50 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6563 |

*Highlight* 1936-s Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms67
Watch
*Highlight* 1936-s Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms67
High Bid: 5.00 USD
1,284.38 - 1,284.38 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6587 |

*Highlight* 1914-p Buffalo Nickel 5c ms66+ SEGS (f
Watch
*Highlight* 1914-p Buffalo Nickel 5c ms66+ SEGS (f
High Bid: 5.00 USD
1,768.75 - 1,768.75 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6611 |

*Highlight* 1916-s Buffalo Nickel 5c ms65+ SEGS (f
Watch
*Highlight* 1916-s Buffalo Nickel 5c ms65+ SEGS (f
High Bid: 5.00 USD
2,306.25 - 2,306.25 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6635 |

*Highlight* 1937-d 3 Leg Buffalo Nickel 5c Select
Watch
*Highlight* 1937-d 3 Leg Buffalo Nickel 5c Select
High Bid: 120.00 USD
2,312.50 - 2,312.50 USD
2 Bids
Lot 6655 |

*Highlight* 1888 Proof Liberty Nickel Near Top Pop
Watch
*Highlight* 1888 Proof Liberty Nickel Near Top Pop
High Bid: 5.00 USD
4,687.50 - 4,687.50 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6659 |

*Highlight* 1925-p Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms67
Watch
*Highlight* 1925-p Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms67
High Bid: 5.00 USD
4,593.75 - 4,593.75 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6683 |

*Highlight* 1931-s Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms67
Watch
*Highlight* 1931-s Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms67
High Bid: 5.00 USD
11,250.00 - 11,250.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6707 |

*Highlight* 1913-p Ty I Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c
Watch
*Highlight* 1913-p Ty I Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c
High Bid: 5.00 USD
13,562.50 - 13,562.50 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6731 |

*Highlight* 1938-d/s Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms
Watch
*Highlight* 1938-d/s Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms
High Bid: 5.00 USD
15,000.00 - 30,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6755 |

*Highlight* 1935-p Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
Watch
*Highlight* 1935-p Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
High Bid: 5.00 USD
15,625.00 - 15,625.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6779 |

*Highlight* 1938-d Buffalo Nickel Colorfully Toned
Watch
*Highlight* 1938-d Buffalo Nickel Colorfully Toned
High Bid: 0.00 USD
6,937.50 - 6,937.50 USD
0 Bids
Lot 6803 |

*Highlight* 1913-d Ty II Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5
Watch
*Highlight* 1913-d Ty II Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5
High Bid: 0.00 USD
9,000.00 - 9,000.00 USD
0 Bids
Lot 6827 |

*Highlight* 1916-d Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c
Watch
*Highlight* 1916-d Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c
High Bid: 0.00 USD
9,187.50 - 9,187.50 USD
0 Bids
Lot 6851 |

*Highlight* 1926-p Buffalo Nickel 5c ms66+ SEGS (f
Watch
*Highlight* 1926-p Buffalo Nickel 5c ms66+ SEGS (f
High Bid: 0.00 USD
568.75 - 568.75 USD
0 Bids
Lot 6863 |

1883 n/c Liberty Nickel 5c Grades GEM+ Unc
Watch
1883 n/c Liberty Nickel 5c Grades GEM+ Unc
High Bid: 0.00 USD
206.25 - 206.25 USD
0 Bids
Lot 6875 |

*Highlight* 1930-p DDO FS-101 Buffalo Nickel TOP P
Watch
*Highlight* 1930-p DDO FS-101 Buffalo Nickel TOP P
High Bid: 0.00 USD
700.00 - 1,400.00 USD
0 Bids
Lot 6899 |

*Highlight* 1913-p Ty II Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5
Watch
*Highlight* 1913-p Ty II Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5
High Bid: 0.00 USD
3,968.75 - 3,968.75 USD
0 Bids
Lot 6923 |

*Highlight* 1938-d Buffalo Nickel Colorfully Toned
Watch
*Highlight* 1938-d Buffalo Nickel Colorfully Toned
High Bid: 0.00 USD
1,165.63 - 1,165.63 USD
0 Bids
Lot 6947 |

*Highlight* 1937-d 3 Leg Buffalo Nickel Mint Error
Watch
*Highlight* 1937-d 3 Leg Buffalo Nickel Mint Error
High Bid: 5.00 USD
3,312.50 - 3,312.50 USD
1 Bid
Lot 6959 |

*Highlight* 1938-d/s Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms
Watch
*Highlight* 1938-d/s Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms
High Bid: 0.00 USD
11,062.50 - 11,062.50 USD
0 Bids
Lot 6966 |

*Highlight* 1912-d Liberty Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms67
Watch
*Highlight* 1912-d Liberty Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms67
High Bid: 0.00 USD
22,500.00 - 22,500.00 USD
0 Bids
Lot 6971 |

*Highlight* 1924-p Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms67
Watch
*Highlight* 1924-p Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms67
High Bid: 0.00 USD
14,937.50 - 14,937.50 USD
0 Bids
Lot 6995 |

*Highlight* 1931-s Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms67
Watch
*Highlight* 1931-s Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms67
High Bid: 0.00 USD
11,250.00 - 11,250.00 USD
0 Bids
Lot 7002 |

*Highlight* 1909 Proof Liberty Nickel Rainbow Tone
Watch
*Highlight* 1909 Proof Liberty Nickel Rainbow Tone
High Bid: 0.00 USD
8,000.00 - 16,000.00 USD
0 Bids
Lot 7019 |

*Highlight* 1917-p Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c
Watch
*Highlight* 1917-p Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c
High Bid: 0.00 USD
7,250.00 - 7,250.00 USD
0 Bids
Lot 7031 |

*Highlight* 1938-d/d Buffalo Nickel 5c ms67+ SEGS
Watch
*Highlight* 1938-d/d Buffalo Nickel 5c ms67+ SEGS
High Bid: 0.00 USD
4,590.63 - 4,590.63 USD
0 Bids
Lot 7043 |

*Highlight* 1936-p Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c
Watch
*Highlight* 1936-p Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c
High Bid: 0.00 USD
3,737.50 - 3,737.50 USD
0 Bids
Lot 7046 |

*Highlight* 1940-d Jefferson Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms
Watch
*Highlight* 1940-d Jefferson Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms
High Bid: 5.00 USD
5,500.00 - 11,000.00 USD
1 Bid
Lot 7055 |

*Highlight* 1915-p Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c
Watch
*Highlight* 1915-p Buffalo Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c
High Bid: 0.00 USD
9,593.75 - 9,593.75 USD
0 Bids
Lot 7067 |

*Highlight* 1913-p Ty I Buffalo Nickel Near Top Po
Watch
*Highlight* 1913-p Ty I Buffalo Nickel Near Top Po
High Bid: 0.00 USD
4,750.00 - 4,750.00 USD
0 Bids
Lot 7074 |

*Highlight* 1889 RPD FS-301 Liberty Nickel TOP POP
Watch
*Highlight* 1889 RPD FS-301 Liberty Nickel TOP POP
High Bid: 0.00 USD
1,625.00 - 1,625.00 USD
0 Bids
Lot 7081 |

*Highlight* 1881 Proof Three Cent Copper Nickel TO
Watch
*Highlight* 1881 Proof Three Cent Copper Nickel TO
High Bid: 0.00 USD
3,000.00 - 6,000.00 USD
0 Bids
Lot 7091 |

*Highlight* 1938-d Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
Watch
*Highlight* 1938-d Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
High Bid: 0.00 USD
6,937.50 - 6,937.50 USD
0 Bids
Lot 7115 |

*Highlight* 1913-d Ty I Buffalo Nickel Near Top Po
Watch
*Highlight* 1913-d Ty I Buffalo Nickel Near Top Po
High Bid: 0.00 USD
7,468.75 - 7,468.75 USD
0 Bids
Lot 7139 |

*Highlight* 1935-d Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms67
Watch
*Highlight* 1935-d Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms67
High Bid: 0.00 USD
8,031.25 - 8,031.25 USD
0 Bids
Lot 7151 |

*Highlight* 1889 Liberty Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c m
Watch
*Highlight* 1889 Liberty Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c m
High Bid: 0.00 USD
2,331.25 - 2,331.25 USD
0 Bids
Lot 7163 |

*Highlight* 1937-s Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
Watch
*Highlight* 1937-s Buffalo Nickel TOP POP! 5c ms68
High Bid: 0.00 USD
9,000.00 - 9,000.00 USD
0 Bids
Lot 7187 |

*Highlight* 1938-d/s FS-512 Buffalo Nickel TOP POP
Watch
*Highlight* 1938-d/s FS-512 Buffalo Nickel TOP POP
High Bid: 0.00 USD
15,000.00 - 30,000.00 USD
0 Bids

HiBid.com is a great source of online auctions featuring popular five-cent coins, such as Shield nickels, Liberty Head nickels, Buffalo nickels, and Jefferson nickels. These coins have been minted since 1866, and while most have maximum values in the thousands of dollars, some extremely rare nickels can sell for millions. If you don’t see the item you’re looking for right now, check back again soon. Our website is continually updated, with new auction items in the U.S. Nickels category added often.