Nickels US For Sale In NEW YORK - Live and Online Auction Lots

Nickels US For Sale In NEW YORK
Auctions Map Lots
Hide Search Bar
Shipping Available
Single Page
Showing 1 to 100 of 191 lots
Lot 9sc |

1909 Liberty Nickel PR63 PCGS
Watch
1909 Liberty Nickel PR63 PCGS
408.75 - 490.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 15sc |

1876 Shield Nickel VF Uncertified #231
Watch
1876 Shield Nickel VF Uncertified #231
217.50 - 261.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 27sc |

1924-D Buffalo Nickel EF40 ANACS
Watch
1924-D Buffalo Nickel EF40 ANACS
310.00 - 372.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 29sc |

1913-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 AU Uncertified #949
Watch
1913-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 AU Uncertified #949
326.25 - 391.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 36sc |

1912-S Liberty Nickel F Uncertified #1116
Watch
1912-S Liberty Nickel F Uncertified #1116
255.00 - 306.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 66sc |

1872 Shield Nickel VF Uncertified #1255
Watch
1872 Shield Nickel VF Uncertified #1255
190.00 - 228.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 78sc |

1912-S Liberty Nickel VG Uncertified #303
Watch
1912-S Liberty Nickel VG Uncertified #303
222.50 - 267.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 85sc |

1913-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 EF45 PCGS
Watch
1913-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 EF45 PCGS
365.00 - 438.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 103sc |

1863 1C Indian Cent - Type 2 Copper-Nickel PCGS
Watch
1863 1C Indian Cent - Type 2 Copper-Nickel PCGS
535.00 - 642.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 112sc |

1900 Liberty Nickel MS64 NGC
Watch
1900 Liberty Nickel MS64 NGC
305.00 - 366.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 140sc |

1924-D Buffalo Nickel EF Uncertified #228
Watch
1924-D Buffalo Nickel EF Uncertified #228
266.25 - 319.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 151sc |

1886 LIBERTY HEAD V NICKEL 5C NGC CERTIFIED F
Watch
1886 LIBERTY HEAD V NICKEL 5C NGC CERTIFIED F
272.50 - 327.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 156sc |

1921-S Buffalo Nickel F Uncertified #214
Watch
1921-S Buffalo Nickel F Uncertified #214
255.00 - 306.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 167sc |

1931-S Buffalo Nickel DDR 1 MS65 PCGS
Watch
1931-S Buffalo Nickel DDR 1 MS65 PCGS
546.25 - 655.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 194sc |

1923-S Buffalo Nickel Choice VF Uncertified #848
Watch
1923-S Buffalo Nickel Choice VF Uncertified #848
190.00 - 228.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 200sc |

1914-D Buffalo Nickel EF Uncertified #306
Watch
1914-D Buffalo Nickel EF Uncertified #306
310.00 - 372.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 205sc |

1937-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 5C NGC MS67
Watch
1937-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 5C NGC MS67
547.50 - 657.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 219sc |

1907 Liberty Nickel MS64 NGC
Watch
1907 Liberty Nickel MS64 NGC
326.25 - 391.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 220sc |

1919-S Buffalo Nickel EF Uncertified #927
Watch
1919-S Buffalo Nickel EF Uncertified #927
343.75 - 412.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 231sc |

1913-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 F Uncertified #147
Watch
1913-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 F Uncertified #147
233.75 - 280.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 247sc |

1925-S Buffalo Nickel EF Uncertified #113
Watch
1925-S Buffalo Nickel EF Uncertified #113
233.75 - 280.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 268sc |

1913 Buffalo Nickel Type I 5C NGC MS65
Watch
1913 Buffalo Nickel Type I 5C NGC MS65
237.50 - 285.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 270sc |

1883 Shield Nickel MS64 PCGS
Watch
1883 Shield Nickel MS64 PCGS
436.25 - 523.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 279sc |

1915-D Buffalo Nickel BU Uncertified #714
Watch
1915-D Buffalo Nickel BU Uncertified #714
343.75 - 412.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 315sc |

1912-S Liberty Nickel F Uncertified #234
Watch
1912-S Liberty Nickel F Uncertified #234
255.00 - 306.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 333sc |

1866 Shield Nickel Rays F-5 EF Uncertified #200
Watch
1866 Shield Nickel Rays F-5 EF Uncertified #200
266.25 - 319.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 357sc |

1916 5C Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65
Watch
1916 5C Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65
386.25 - 463.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 368sc |

1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel OMM FS-512 MS64 PCGS
Watch
1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel OMM FS-512 MS64 PCGS
190.00 - 228.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 382sc |

1918-D Buffalo Nickel AU53 NGC
Watch
1918-D Buffalo Nickel AU53 NGC
480.00 - 576.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 384sc |

1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel FS-513 Choice BU++
Watch
1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel FS-513 Choice BU++
190.00 - 228.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 412sc |

1872 Shield Nickel DDO VF Uncertified
Watch
1872 Shield Nickel DDO VF Uncertified
190.00 - 228.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 449sc |

1913-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 Choice EF
Watch
1913-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 Choice EF
305.00 - 366.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 475sc |

1924-S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 5C NGC F15
Watch
1924-S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 5C NGC F15
207.50 - 249.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 487sc |

1913-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 AU53 PCGS
Watch
1913-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 AU53 PCGS
353.75 - 424.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 500sc |

1876 Shield Nickel VF Uncertified #1213
Watch
1876 Shield Nickel VF Uncertified #1213
217.50 - 261.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 501sc |

1912-S Liberty Nickel VG Uncertified #308
Watch
1912-S Liberty Nickel VG Uncertified #308
222.50 - 267.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 503sc |

1872 Shield Nickel VF Uncertified #222
Watch
1872 Shield Nickel VF Uncertified #222
190.00 - 228.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 529sc |

1915-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 5C NGC AU58
Watch
1915-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 5C NGC AU58
262.50 - 315.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 533sc |

1921-S Buffalo Nickel VF Uncertified #847
Watch
1921-S Buffalo Nickel VF Uncertified #847
408.75 - 490.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 539sc |

1912-S Liberty Nickel F Uncertified #1122
Watch
1912-S Liberty Nickel F Uncertified #1122
255.00 - 306.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 542sc |

1915-D Buffalo Nickel AU Slider Uncertified #106
Watch
1915-D Buffalo Nickel AU Slider Uncertified #106
245.00 - 294.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 553sc |

1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel FS-515 MS64 PCGS
Watch
1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel FS-515 MS64 PCGS
217.50 - 261.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 591sc |

1911 Liberty Nickel MS64 ANACS
Watch
1911 Liberty Nickel MS64 ANACS
288.75 - 346.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 597sc |

1956 Jefferson Nickel TDR FS-802 MS65 PCGS
Watch
1956 Jefferson Nickel TDR FS-802 MS65 PCGS
233.75 - 280.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 619sc |

1936-D Buffalo Nickel MS66 PCGS
Watch
1936-D Buffalo Nickel MS66 PCGS
337.50 - 405.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 627sc |

1866 Shield Nickel Rays AU Uncertified #1021
Watch
1866 Shield Nickel Rays AU Uncertified #1021
298.75 - 358.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 642sc |

1935-S/S Buffalo Nickel RPM 3 MS65 PCGS
Watch
1935-S/S Buffalo Nickel RPM 3 MS65 PCGS
321.25 - 385.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 657sc |

1876 Shield Nickel Choice VF Uncertified #217
Watch
1876 Shield Nickel Choice VF Uncertified #217
238.75 - 286.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 1e |

Group of early Buffalo nickles
Watch
Group of early Buffalo nickles
High Bid: 0.00 USD
50.00 - 60.00 USD
0 Bids
2d 17h 49m
Lot 1f |

Group of early Buffalo nickles
Watch
Group of early Buffalo nickles
High Bid: 0.00 USD
50.00 - 60.00 USD
0 Bids
2d 17h 49m
Lot 1g |

Group of early Buffalo nickles
Watch
High Bid: 0.00 USD
50.00 - 60.00 USD
0 Bids
2d 17h 49m
Lot 1o |

Large collection of early Buffalo nickles
Watch
Large collection of early Buffalo nickles
High Bid: 0.00 USD
175.00 - 200.00 USD
0 Bids
2d 17h 49m
Lot 2w |

Jefferson nickle collection with booklet
Watch
Jefferson nickle collection with booklet
High Bid: 0.00 USD
50.00 - 60.00 USD
0 Bids
2d 17h 49m
Lot 3e |

Collection of US silver war time nickels
Watch
Collection of US silver war time nickels
High Bid: 0.00 USD
50.00 - 60.00 USD
0 Bids
2d 17h 49m
Lot 6o |

Buffalo nickle collection with booklet
Watch
Buffalo nickle collection with booklet
High Bid: 0.00 USD
175.00 - 200.00 USD
0 Bids
2d 17h 49m
Lot 676sc |

1886 LIBERTY HEAD V NICKEL 5C NGC CERTIFIED VG
Watch
1886 LIBERTY HEAD V NICKEL 5C NGC CERTIFIED VG
240.00 - 288.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 1sc |

1920 Buffalo Nickel Type 2 5C NGC MS64
Watch
1920 Buffalo Nickel Type 2 5C NGC MS64
312.50 - 375.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 5sc |

1866 Shield Nickel Rays AU Uncertified #1021
Watch
1866 Shield Nickel Rays AU Uncertified #1021
298.75 - 358.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 21 |

1912-D "V" NICKEL
Watch
1912-D "V" NICKEL
High Bid: 3.00 USD
1 Bid
4d 12h 25m
WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
Lot 13sc |

1920-D Buffalo Nickel EF Uncertified #1049
Watch
1920-D Buffalo Nickel EF Uncertified #1049
337.50 - 405.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 17sc |

1913-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 F Uncertified #161
Watch
1913-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 F Uncertified #161
233.75 - 280.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 18sc |

1883 Shield Nickel MS61 NGC
Watch
1883 Shield Nickel MS61 NGC
277.50 - 333.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 69sc |

1872 Shield Nickel VF Uncertified #224
Watch
1872 Shield Nickel VF Uncertified #224
190.00 - 228.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 93sc |

1955-D D/S Jefferson Nickel 5C NGC MS65
Watch
1955-D D/S Jefferson Nickel 5C NGC MS65
237.50 - 285.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 124sc |

1912-S Liberty Nickel VG Uncertified #315
Watch
1912-S Liberty Nickel VG Uncertified #315
222.50 - 267.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 149sc |

1938-D Buffalo Nickel OMM FS-515 MS65 PCGS
Watch
1938-D Buffalo Nickel OMM FS-515 MS65 PCGS
271.25 - 325.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 159sc |

1921-S Buffalo Nickel F Uncertified #331
Watch
1921-S Buffalo Nickel F Uncertified #331
255.00 - 306.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 166sc |

1926-S Buffalo Nickel Choice VF Uncertified #1114
Watch
1926-S Buffalo Nickel Choice VF Uncertified #1114
442.50 - 531.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 176sc |

1926 S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C ANACS CERTIFIED VF 20
Watch
1926 S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C ANACS CERTIFIED VF 20
212.50 - 255.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 180sc |

1918-S Buffalo Nickel EF Uncertified #310
Watch
1918-S Buffalo Nickel EF Uncertified #310
255.00 - 306.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 202sc |

1876 Shield Nickel Choice VF Uncertified #250
Watch
1876 Shield Nickel Choice VF Uncertified #250
238.75 - 286.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 218sc |

1882 Shield Nickel MS62 PCGS
Watch
1882 Shield Nickel MS62 PCGS
326.25 - 391.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 228sc |

1912-S Liberty Nickel F Uncertified #1105
Watch
1912-S Liberty Nickel F Uncertified #1105
255.00 - 306.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 254sc |

1917 Buffalo Nickel MS63 PCGS
Watch
1917 Buffalo Nickel MS63 PCGS
353.75 - 424.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 267sc |

1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF Uncertified #123
Watch
1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF Uncertified #123
408.75 - 490.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 290sc |

1872 Shield Nickel DDO FS-101 AU Uncertified #107
Watch
1872 Shield Nickel DDO FS-101 AU Uncertified #107
245.00 - 294.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 304sc |

1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF Uncertified #124
Watch
1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF Uncertified #124
408.75 - 490.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 308sc |

1939 Jefferson Nickel DDR FS-801 AU Uncertified
Watch
1939 Jefferson Nickel DDR FS-801 AU Uncertified
245.00 - 294.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 311sc |

1867 Shield Nickel Rays VF Uncertified #543
Watch
1867 Shield Nickel Rays VF Uncertified #543
190.00 - 228.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 323sc |

1865 Three Cent Nickel RPD FS-302 BU Uncertified
Watch
1865 Three Cent Nickel RPD FS-302 BU Uncertified
353.75 - 424.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 337sh |

Collection of 5 1963 5C Jefferson Nickels all in
Watch
Collection of 5 1963 5C Jefferson Nickels all in
245.00 - 294.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 1d 19m
Lot 369sc |

1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 G Uncertified #305
Watch
1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 G Uncertified #305
245.00 - 294.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 395sc |

1876 Shield Nickel AU Uncertified #1122
Watch
1876 Shield Nickel AU Uncertified #1122
298.75 - 358.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 399sc |

1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Watch
1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
245.00 - 294.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 406sc |

1912-S Liberty Nickel VG Uncertified #316
Watch
1912-S Liberty Nickel VG Uncertified #316
222.50 - 267.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 413sc |

1914-D Buffalo Nickel EF Uncertified #848
Watch
1914-D Buffalo Nickel EF Uncertified #848
310.00 - 372.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 465sc |

1872 Shield Nickel DDO F-117 EF Uncertified #912
Watch
1872 Shield Nickel DDO F-117 EF Uncertified #912
200.00 - 240.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 476sc |

1926-S Buffalo Nickel Choice VF Uncertified #1114
Watch
1926-S Buffalo Nickel Choice VF Uncertified #1114
442.50 - 531.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 493sc |

1928-D Buffalo Nickel MS64 NGC
Watch
1928-D Buffalo Nickel MS64 NGC
343.75 - 412.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 511sc |

1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF Uncertified #132
Watch
1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF Uncertified #132
408.75 - 490.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 525sc |

1888 Three Cent Piece - Copper Nickel 3CN NGC AU
Watch
1888 Three Cent Piece - Copper Nickel 3CN NGC AU
268.75 - 322.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 535sc |

1882 Shield Nickel RPD MS62 PCGS
Watch
1882 Shield Nickel RPD MS62 PCGS
332.50 - 399.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 547sc |

1912-S Liberty Nickel F Uncertified #1120
Watch
1912-S Liberty Nickel F Uncertified #1120
255.00 - 306.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 575sc |

1923-S Buffalo Nickel EF Uncertified #1140
Watch
1923-S Buffalo Nickel EF Uncertified #1140
326.25 - 391.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 586sc |

1883 5C No CENTS Liberty V Nickel No "CENTS" PCGS
Watch
1883 5C No CENTS Liberty V Nickel No "CENTS" PCGS
331.25 - 397.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 604sc |

1912-S Liberty Nickel F Uncertified #1128
Watch
1912-S Liberty Nickel F Uncertified #1128
255.00 - 306.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 605sc |

1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 VF Uncertified #921
Watch
1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 VF Uncertified #921
486.25 - 583.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 612sc |

1864 Indian Cent Copper Nickel AU53 PCGS
Watch
1864 Indian Cent Copper Nickel AU53 PCGS
245.00 - 294.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 632sc |

1867 Shield Nickel Rays EF Uncertified #241
Watch
1867 Shield Nickel Rays EF Uncertified #241
298.75 - 358.50 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m
Lot 647sc |

1876 Shield Nickel VF Uncertified #1142
Watch
1876 Shield Nickel VF Uncertified #1142
217.50 - 261.00 USD
Reserve Not Met
Bidding opens in 3d 19m

HiBid.com is a great source of online auctions featuring popular five-cent coins, such as Shield nickels, Liberty Head nickels, Buffalo nickels, and Jefferson nickels. These coins have been minted since 1866, and while most have maximum values in the thousands of dollars, some extremely rare nickels can sell for millions. If you don’t see the item you’re looking for right now, check back again soon. Our website is continually updated, with new auction items in the U.S. Nickels category added often.